19' 0-1 Marouane Fellaini [Everton] 23' 0-2 Tim Cahill [Everton] 33' 1-2 John Carew [Aston Villa] 54' 1-3 Steven Pienaar [Everton] 55' 2-3 James Milner [Aston Villa] 67' 3-3 (pen) Gareth Barry [Aston Villa] FINAL